16 Comments
User's avatar
Sidney Eley's avatar

I love that you choose this painting to talk about today. We are in 'the troubles' as well. This is a work I had not seen before and because it's quite busy, I would never have taken the time to really look at it or try to see the larger picture of the time it was painted in or the bravery of the artist.

I so appreciate your work. Thanks

Expand full comment
George Bothamley's avatar

Yes, there are aspects of this that certainly do feel a little too relavent at the moment! But I’m really glad to know this helped you to see the work in a way that you may not otherwise.

Thank you for your support. It is much appreciated.

Expand full comment
Here To Listen's avatar

Also George, another political point for Botticelli was the turmoil in Florence which resulted in the family he was informally adopted by and who solely supported his career being persecuted. At the time, Florence was in political chaos after the expulsion of the Medici family in 1494. The city was seen as sinful and in need of redemption. The painting’s theme of divine intervention may reflect Botticelli’s hope for Florence’s spiritual rebirth.

Expand full comment
George Bothamley's avatar

Really impressed by your knowledge! You’re absolutely right. I actually considered going into the political situation a bit more too - but just felt it would extend the essay a little too long today.

Expand full comment
Tricia Fields's avatar

What a fascinating read! You mentioned sharing more information about Girolamo Savonarola on a future post. I would love to learn more about him.

Expand full comment
George Bothamley's avatar

Thanks a lot. I must admit, it’s been on my mind for a long time to dedicae a special edition to Savanorola as there is so much to say about him.

So I can’t promise anything - but it way well happen at some point!

Expand full comment
Mike Isaac's avatar

Superb choice as usual! Some of these ideas are explored by Edgar Wind in his ‘Pagan Mysteries in the Renaissance’ - an oldie (1960s) but a goodie. But your piece is a model of information and conciseness. Thank you!

Expand full comment
George Bothamley's avatar

Thanks a lot, Mike - that’s kind of you to say. And thanks for the book recommendation too - I’ve not heard of that one, so I’ll definitely look it up.

Expand full comment
Jo Thompson's avatar

This was on my shortlist for my Five Favourites!

Expand full comment
George Bothamley's avatar

Yes, i remember smiling to myself when seeing it on your list as it’s a piece I’ve had ready to dive deeper into for a while!

And I’m sure that just like all your other choices, we would have so much to discuss about this one. :)

Expand full comment
Susan Scheid's avatar

Fascinating to learn of the Botticelli-Savonarola connection. This adds yet another enticement to add (somehow in my lifetime) reading about medieval and Renaissance Florentine history. I am participating in a slow read of Dante‘s Divine Comedy here on Substack, and medieval Florentine politics enter in quite a lot. In Canto X, we meet Farinata, an adversary in Florence who Dante admired (even though he placed him in the 6th circle of hell). I see a lot of Botticelli-like spiritual struggle in Dante, too. Dante admired the classical poets, Virgil chief among them, yet because they were “pagan,” his medieval Catholicism required him to bar them from Paradise. Farinata’s fate was even worse. For one, he was an Epicurean. Yet that Dante admired him shows in Canto X—and he should admire this man: when Farinata and his partisans won in battle and his compatriots proposed razing Florence to the ground, he was the only one who stood in the way, earning the moniker “Savior of Florence.” For that alone, to my modern mind, he earned a place in Paradise.

Expand full comment
John's avatar

Lovely and pertinent analysis. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Wells Of Goodness's avatar

Fascinating, as always, George. I love your ending: “Yes. Italy (USA) is in trouble . . . and the world is falling apart . . . and we really are deeply in need of a saviour . . . but, nonetheless, I, Sandro, will continue to bring beauty into life”. So relevant. Thank you!

Expand full comment
George Bothamley's avatar

Thanks Melanie. Yes, I must admit I didn’t realise how relevant this was to our modern times until I was actually writing it.

Expand full comment
Oluseyi Akinyode's avatar

Wow, just thinking of the paintings by Botticelli that hot destroyed!

Expand full comment
George Bothamley's avatar

Yes, how amazing would it be to know what the pieces looked like!

Expand full comment