Giovanni Bellini - Monochrome Masterpiece

From the middle of the 15th century, and into the early 16th - Giovanni Bellini was regarded as one of the most talented artists of his generation within his home city of Venice.

A master of painting with oils (which, at the time, was still far from the common medium for artists who often worked in egg tempera instead) . . . he brought a luxuriant depth of colour to Venetian art. And, later in life, was a key influence in the early career of one of Venice’s other great geniuses too - the legendary Titian, who served as an apprentice in Giovanni’s workshop while still a teenager.

However, the picture I wanted us to focus on today is actually entirely different to the rest of his colourful oeuvre.

A rare monochrome masterpiece - and, in my opinion, a truly mesmerizing study of human emotion.

Giovanni Bellini - Lamentation over the Dead Christ - 1495 (Uffizi, Florence)

Incidentally, Giovanni Bellini is by no means the only member of the Bellini family who came to prominence in the Venetian art world of the time.

We have also inherited artwork from one Jacapo Bellini (widely considered to be Giovanni’s father - although, for the sake of accuracy, I should also mention that academics have more recently been touting the possibility that Jacapo was actually a much older brother instead.)

And there is another famous brother too - the artist Gentile Bellini - who tended to specialise in portraiture.

Plus - Giovanni’s sister, Nicolosia, had also married quite a famous artist of the time too, by the name of Andrea Mantegna!

So, in some sense, the Bellini/Mantegna household really were a bit of a powerhouse in the art world of the time.

Yet, as the years would tell, it was the youngest of them all - Giovanni - who would become the most well known. And with a painting like his Lamentation, it is clear to see why . . . because, here, with all colour stripped back, and we are exposed fully to his mastery of shade and form.

Of course, the scene is a biblical narrative - showing us the apostles and Mary, the Mother of Jesus, lamenting over the recently crucified Christ.

But, more than that, the painting can be interpreted as a stunning representation of the stages of grief - with each figure embodying a different shade of hurt, confusion, anger, fear, and regret over the loss of this man they had so loved.

Also, it is worth noting that while this may look like a pencil or charcoal drawing - it is actually a painting. (Again, yet another testament to the artist’s skill of illusion!)

And in fact, there something of an ongoing debate in modern scholarship over what Giovanni’s ultimate intention was for this picture.

Is it a detailed study for a future work (possibly now lost)?

Could it be the first stages of an underpainting for a piece he never actually completed?

Or, did the artist really paint this as a monochrome piece from the start? (In which case, it deserves even more credit as an experimental and boundary breaking artwork for Giovanni!)

Personally, I tend to think that the figures are too finely painted to be just a study . . . and that far too much care has been taken over the subtle lighting and details here for this to be anything less than an intentional, and fully completed, work!

But, of course, the mystery remains.

So . . . what do you think?

---

---

Bonus Section